1. Hark! The Herald Angels Sing (Luther Dickinson)
2. Pretty Paper (Robert Ellis)
3. The First Noel (Emmylou Harris)
4. The Gifts They Gave (Johnny Cash)
5. Just Me And These Ponies (For Christmas This Year) (Corb Lund)
6. Winter Wonderland (Valerie June)
7. Must Be Santa (Bob Dylan)
8. At Christmas Time (The Common Linnets)
9. Les Trois Cloches (Ben Keith w/ Neil & Pegi Young)
10. Season of Memory (Max Gomez)
11. FaLaLaLaLove Ya (Nikki Lane)
12. Here It Is Christmas Time (Old 97's)
13. Christmas Must Be Tonight (The Band)